Friday, June 17, 2011

Question Corner: How to Kill Brook?

There are many unique and interesting Devil Fruit abilities in the One Piece world. You have one that can make a person into rubber while others can grant a person to become lava and there is even one that allows the user to become a giraffe. Still one of the strangest powers seems to be Brook's Yomi Yomi ability.

 The Yomi Yomi fruit basically give the user an 'extra life'. The person that eats it won't see anything different outside the inability to swim while they are alive the first time around. It is when they die that they experience the ability of the fruit. They are then revived and live as if nothing happen. Anybody who is familiar with video games would see that it is basically another life. You die and then come back to life. The only problem is that you (as a soul) have to find your body before it decomposes.

The fruit doesn't give the person immortality though. Brook has showed several instances where he claims that he can die even though half of the time he follows with "But I am already dead! Yohohohoho~". The point is that even Brook knows that he can die. The question is how.

Brook has a severe case of Phantom Limb where everything that he had before seems to be apart of his power. He is able to eat, breath, and feel as if he has his old body parts and organs. So I would say you can just stab Brook in the stomach and that be it. Still this would only work if Brook actually had a stomach if he had found his body in time. This is a hidden advantage that Brook has gained due to taking so long in getting back to his body thus eliminating normal ways to kill him.

This only leaves more 'creative' ways to kill Brook. This could include the use of SeaPrism Stones or throwing him in the ocean. The question is will he actually die from these things or actions? There has to be a way to kill a living skeleton.

So what are your ideas on how Brook can die? Can he die like a normal person or does something 'creative' can happen. What do you think needs to happen for Brook to die? Will Oda ever answer this question? Who knows but we can take guesses until that time comes.

Question: What (/How) are ways that Brook could die?

6 comments:

  1. I see it like the fruits have one purpose. With Luffy, his fruit's purpose was "Make this boy rubber". Luffy learned to do shit like Gears but all the fruit is doing is making him rubber.

    Same with Brooks. His fruit was "Bring him back to life". A body with no ability to breath or eat wouldn't be alive. The fruit brought him back to life, but but almost like little "portals" in Brook. He can eat and the food obviously doesn't go down through his mouth. It seems to vanish to the parts of his body that weren't revived in the after life. He shits it out but because the shit didn't die(Because it can't) it comes out of living Brook.

    In a sense the parts of Brook's body that were decomposed are in the afterlife and still functioning there, but what could be salvaged stayed connected but alive on earth.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. wow so what r u saying about the body that if he did once again i say did what my take place

      Delete
  2. I don't know, maybe if you crushed the skull or broke the spine it would kill him like anyone else. But then, he doesn't really need them for the lack of organs...

    ReplyDelete
  3. I guess it could be done the classic ol' way just like other devil fruit user, tie some huge ass rock to him, throw him over board and let the sea do the magic

    ReplyDelete
  4. Burn him i dont know but i think throwing him in the ocean is proabbly what every body would think about if we were to see brook die

    ReplyDelete